Saturday 1 October 2016

LETTER TO THE HONORABLE PRIME MINISTER OF INDIA
From 
Inderjit Singh
(Doyen of OROP Movement)
Oct 01, 2016 

Dear Sh Narendra Modi my Chotte Bhai Saheb,

Every leader is mincing no words while saying 'INDIAN ARMY HAS MADE NATION PROUD.'

Indian Army has always made India proud
There is nothing new about it? What have the Indian Armed Forces got in return. Can the Armed Forces also say this about their political leadership and the powers that run our great Nation?  If I say 'NO NOT AT ALL' I will not be telling any lies. 

Greatest Achievement 

The greatest of their achievements was victory in the Indo Pak War in 1971 when they broke India's  enemy into two Nations and captured over 90,000 POWs. Thereby eliminating threat to the Nation of having to fight on two fronts  every time  Pakistan threatened India, for all times to come. What did the Armed Forces get in return. Down gradation of their status and reduction of their pensions from 73 % of their salaries to 50 % as pensions? This was also the beginning of systematic down gradation of their salaries and status.

Systematic Down Gradation

First Major Shock.  Every time the revision was done the Armed Forces were down graded and facilities reduced. If they questioned they were told this was all that they could get. Take it or lump it. The Sixth CPC left them aghast with degradation further when they were the only Service not granted NFFU along with with many more anomalies. The matter was taken up with the leadership but nothing came out of that till today. 

Another Bombshell.  While the matter is still under consideration of the Govt, another bombshell has been delivered with 7th CPC award. When the Chiefs took it up with our worthy Raksha Mantri they were brusquely told to go and implement it first and then their request will be considered. More amazing was his reply to you my Chhote Bhai Saheb, when after meeting the Chiefs you asked him why these anomalies could not be removed before the Notification was issued. His answer to you was amazing. His answer was that Cabinets decision once taken can't be changed before the Notification was issued. The surprising aspect of this matter was that you accepted this ridiculous statement without any comment. I know of cases when after the Cabinet has taken a decision about a matter, the concerned Ministry referring back to the Cabinet for reconsideration.

OROP Struggle - Contemptuous Treatment.  The latest and most degrading of these all, is the Veterans ongoing struggle for OROP for the past over 470 days at Jantar Mantar. A major unforgivable blot on all leadership. The Veterans are seeking the 'ASLI OROP' that you have promised  them before and after the Elections. Nothing more nothing less. Need I say that your absolute majority is only for their whole hearted support to you. You doubt it? If you do then you may continue with your disastrous policy of following the dictates of bureaucrats about matters pertaining to the Armed Forces and see the results in the next General Elections. The amazing and shocking aspect of all this  is that you have even refused to meet any of these Veterans leave alone solve their problems.   
Why ? Are they untouchables that a Pradhan Sewak doesn't want to see them? This being done to those who make the Nation proud every time, is most heart rending.

OROP Easily Implementable

The Veterans are your admirers for what you said before elections and want to continue to be so.It is time to mend the fences. Please take action to do it soon and before it is too late. Whoever tells you that OROP is not implementable is a blatant lier. I am the person who raised it with the Hon'ble PM, the first time on 22 Feb 1982 and struggled all these years for it and got it twice before. From the Congress Govt in 1990 through a High Level Empowered Committee (HELC) headed by RM in the form of One Time Increase  (OTI)  formula and second time from UPA Govt on 25 Jan 2006, through a Group of Minister Committee headed by RM, who now is The President of India. It was easily implemented both times by those very people who are misleading you now.  

Draft Govt Letter Issued In April 2014

The third time we got it announced on 17 Feb 2014 by the UPA. They were in the process of implementation when the Govt fell. The Govt however before falling, had in consultation with Veterans prepared a Draft Govt Letter which was to be issued shortly. Even a Chief was asked to announce that to Veterans by your Govt, which he did. The bureaucrats dilly dallied over it in the hope they would be able to wriggle out of it with your Govt and they did by projecting blatant lies about it. How sad ? Its implementation will not only solve this long standing problem but will also save the precious time of  CPC for working out pensions every time.     

I have written to you despite being paralysed for the last twenty months waiting for my flight to my Heavenly abode.  All because I wish that you continue to serve the Nation for long time as PRADHAN SEWAK. You take it or leave it. Despite my problems I am prepared to come and pay you my regards and clarify what I have said about OROP or any other matter.

Congratulation For Bold Decision

Heartiest Congratulations for allowing the Armed Forces to do their job to make the Nation proud. I hope that you will take equally strong decision to put another matter write for the Armed Forces. What is needed I wrote you soon after you assumed charge. You had accepted and issued instructions about two of these matters i.e. Ex servicemen Commission and SCOVA, but the bureaucrats have yet to constitute these even after two years. It will be interesting for you to know the reasons for the delay.If these were in position, the Reddy Committee hopping around India meaninglessly wasting time and expense would not be necessary. The acceptable solution would have been worked out after in house discussions as we did for DGL early 2014.

I am aware that this appeal may never be allowed to reach your desk, I am, therefore, sending it to all those who matter with the hope that some well meaning person like me would reach it to you.

BUREAUCRATIC REPLY 
RECEIVED BY LT COL INDERJIT SINGH

 F.No. 12(83)/2016/D(P/P)
                                                                      Ministry of Defence
                                                                      Department of Ex-Servicemen Welfare
                                                                      D(Pension/Policy)
                                                                      New Delhi, 
                                                                      Dated 26th September 2016
To,
       Lt. Col Inderjit Singh(Retd)
       Chairman, All lIndia Ex-Services Welfare Association
       M-35, Palika Bhawan, R.K. Puram, Sector-XII
       New Delhi - 110066

Sir,
       Please refer to your letter no. 4020/AIEWA/189/VIP-I dated 01.07.2016, regarding implementation of One Rank One Pension (OROP).  The para wise reply to the letter dated 1st July 2016 is as follows:

2.       Para 1-7: No specific grievances and appeal has been made by the applicant.

3.       Para 8(a) : On the recommendations of Parliamentary Consultative Committee.
DoPPW has constituted Standing Committee of Voluntary Associations (SCOVA) with 15 Non-Official members (5 Standing Group and 10 Rotating Group Members) represented by the Pensioners Associations from various Ministries/Departments/ Regions/States etc.  The forum is useful for holding consultation
with stakeholders i.e. the pensioners through their Associations and concerned Ministries/Departments. MoD is a member of the Committee and there seems to be no need for separate SCOVA for MoD.

Para 8(b) : Department of Ex-Servicemen Welfare is headed by Secretary and staffed by civilians and decision are taken after due consultation with Service Headquarters.

Para 8 (c) & (d) : Department of Ex-Servicemen Welfare (DESW) has no comments to offer.

Para 8(e) : With regards to Ex-Servicemen Resettement Commission it is stated that Director General of Resettlement (DGR) already exist for the resettlement of welfare of Ex-Servicemen (ESM).

Para 9-11 : Department of Ex-Servicemen Welfare (DESW) has no comments to offr.

Para 12 : With regards to grant of One Rank One Pension (OROP) it is stated that detailed instructions for implementation of OROP has already been issued vide Ministry of Defence's  notification dated 3rd February 2016 and a sum of Rs. 3826.39 Crores has been disbursed to 19,11,023 ESMs/families as on 16.09.2016.

                                                                                                                                                   Sd/xx x x
                                                                                                                                                   (Manoj Sinha)
                                                                                                   Under Secretary to Government of India

Copy to : Deputy Secretary, Political Section, PMO, South Block - For information with

                 respect to ID No. 4441158/PMO/2016-Pol dated 14.07.2016.

COMMENTS OF LT COL INDERJIT SINGH
TO THE REPLY RECEIVED

We should expect nothing from this bureaucracy. 

For last 36 years we twice got approval of whatever we projected, including OROP, from the leadership, only by projecting facts directly to the top political leadership. 

Since that is missing now and I don't see anybody capable of establishing personal equation and relations with the leadership,

we can forget it. 

6 comments:

  1. This will not reach as envisaged.Long you live Col Inderjeet

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Dear and respected Inderjeet Sir. I will try my best to get your missive sent out on all forums. I can only promise but let us hope and pray. Warm regards yours humbly. Lt Col Sukhwant Singh(Retd). better known as Sukhi and @simba49 on Twitter.

    ReplyDelete
  4. First and foremost best wishes for good health and hats off to your spirit. Even if your plea is delivered to the addressed, doubt any positive outcome especially in the reflected glory of the Army's achievement

    ReplyDelete
  5. Have read your profile sir! A man after my heart.sad about your loneliness. Bless you

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thx Gurnam. You all are my strength. With you all around, i am never lonely.

    ReplyDelete